Peanut Butter Frozen Yogurt – Healthy 5-Ingredient Dessert

There’s something about peanut butter and frozen yogurt that feels instantly nostalgic—like a throwback to carefree summer afternoons, sticky fingers, and ice cream smiles. And when you bring those flavors together in a creamy, dreamy frozen yogurt that’s not only simple to make but also surprisingly healthy? That’s the kind of recipe that earns a permanent spot in your dessert rotation.

This peanut butter frozen yogurt is smooth, rich, and lusciously creamy, yet it comes together with just five pantry-friendly ingredients. You don’t need a fancy ice cream machine (though if you have one, great), and it’s easy to adapt whether you’re dairy-free, vegan, paleo, or even keto. It’s the kind of frozen treat that feels indulgent but doesn’t weigh you down. Plus, it’s totally customizable—think chocolate chips, swirls of jam, or a drizzle of chocolate syrup for that classic peanut butter cup vibe.

What makes this recipe especially magical is how approachable it is. Whether you’re a seasoned home cook or brand new in the kitchen, you’ll be able to whip this up without stress. And let’s be real—there’s nothing quite like digging your spoon into a bowl of homemade frozen yogurt, especially when you know exactly what’s in it.

I first stumbled upon this recipe on a quiet weekend when I was craving something cold and sweet but didn’t want to load up on sugar or fuss with baking. With a half-empty jar of peanut butter and a container of yogurt staring me down, the wheels started turning—and the result was this creamy, nutty, totally satisfying frozen yogurt. It was love at first bite.

Let’s dive into what makes this peanut butter frozen yogurt so special and how you can make it your new go-to dessert.

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

There are plenty of reasons to fall head over heels for this recipe, starting with its irresistible flavor and texture. The combination of tangy yogurt and rich peanut butter creates a luscious base that’s naturally creamy without the need for heavy cream or eggs.

Here’s why you’ll want to make this again and again:

• Simple Ingredients: With just five main ingredients, you can whip this up with what’s already in your kitchen. No obscure items, no grocery trips needed.
• Customizable for Any Diet: Whether you’re vegan, dairy-free, gluten-free, keto, or paleo, this recipe can be tailored to your needs with simple swaps.
• Minimal Equipment Needed: No ice cream maker? No problem. This recipe offers multiple preparation methods—from blender-friendly to a basic freeze-and-stir approach—so you can make it work with what you have.
• Perfectly Creamy Texture: The richness of peanut butter combined with the slight tang of yogurt delivers a balanced, satisfying mouthfeel that’s both light and indulgent.
• Guilt-Free Treat: With natural sweeteners and a solid protein boost from the yogurt and peanut butter, this is a dessert you can feel good about enjoying.
• Kid and Adult Friendly: The flavor is classic and comforting, appealing to picky eaters and foodies alike.

From the first spoonful, this frozen yogurt will have you wondering why you haven’t been making your own all along.

Health Benefits

Peanut butter frozen yogurt doesn’t just taste good—it offers some great nutritional perks, too. Here’s a closer look at why this treat is a healthier choice compared to traditional ice cream:

• Protein Power: Yogurt, especially Greek-style, and peanut butter are both rich in protein, which helps keep you full and supports muscle health.
• Healthy Fats: Natural peanut butter provides monounsaturated fats, which are heart-healthy and beneficial for brain function.
• Lower in Sugar: By using natural sweeteners like honey, maple syrup, bananas, or dates, you can control the sugar content and avoid the refined sugars typically found in store-bought ice creams.
• Gut-Friendly Probiotics: Yogurt contains probiotics that support digestive health and boost your immune system.
• Nutrient-Rich: Peanut butter adds magnesium, potassium, and vitamin E to the mix, all of which are essential for various bodily functions.

So not only are you satisfying your sweet tooth, but you’re also doing your body a favor.

Preparation Time, Servings, and Nutritional Information

Total Time:
Prep time: 10 minutes
Chilling/Freezing time: 3–4 hours (varies by method)
Total: Approx. 4 hours

Servings:
Serves 4

Nutritional Information (per serving):
Calories: 250
Protein: 9g
Carbohydrates: 20g
Fat: 15g
Sugar: 12g
Fiber: 2g

Ingredients List

You’ll only need five core ingredients for this frozen yogurt. Here’s what to grab:

• 1 ½ cups plain or vanilla yogurt (Greek or regular; use dairy-free if needed)
  Provides the creamy, tangy base and loads of probiotics.
• ½ cup milk of choice (dairy or non-dairy like almond, oat, or coconut milk)
  Helps thin the mixture slightly for better blending or churning.
• ⅓ cup natural peanut butter (smooth or crunchy, unsweetened)
  Adds richness, nutty flavor, and satisfying texture.
• 1 pinch of salt
  Balances the sweetness and enhances the nutty notes.
• 2–4 tablespoons sweetener of choice (maple syrup, honey, agave, or mashed ripe banana/dates)
  Customizes the sweetness while keeping it natural.

Optional Add-Ins:

• Mini chocolate chips
• Chocolate syrup or melted chocolate
• Swirls of jam or chopped roasted peanuts

Step-By-Step Cooking Instructions

This recipe can be made using three different methods, depending on what equipment you have on hand. Each one yields creamy, delicious results—just pick the one that suits you best.

1. Ice Cream Maker Method (Best Texture)

1. In a medium bowl, whisk together the yogurt, milk, peanut butter, salt, and sweetener until smooth.
2. Taste and adjust the sweetness if needed.
3. Chill the mixture in the fridge for at least 1 hour.
4. Pour into your ice cream maker and churn according to manufacturer’s instructions (typically 20–25 minutes).
5. Serve immediately for soft-serve texture, or transfer to a freezer-safe container and freeze for 1–2 hours for a firmer consistency.

2. Blender Method (No Ice Cream Maker Needed)

1. Pour the yogurt mixture into ice cube trays and freeze until solid (about 2–3 hours).
2. Once frozen, pop the cubes into a high-speed blender.
3. Blend until smooth and creamy, using a splash of milk as needed to get things moving.
4. Serve immediately, or freeze for up to an hour for a firmer scoop.

3. Freeze-and-Stir Method (Manual Option)

1. Mix all the ingredients in a bowl until smooth.
2. Pour the mixture into a shallow freezer-safe container.
3. Freeze, and every 20–30 minutes, stir vigorously with a fork or whisk to break up ice crystals.
4. Repeat this process for 2–3 hours until the mixture is thick and creamy.

Optional Toppings

Sprinkle on mini chocolate chips, drizzle chocolate syrup, or add chopped peanuts before serving for that classic peanut butter cup flavor.

How to Serve

• Scoop into bowls or cones for a classic presentation.
• Serve in a mason jar with layers of chocolate sauce and banana slices.
• Add a spoonful on top of warm brownies for a contrast of hot and cold.
• Make it a frozen yogurt parfait by layering with granola and fruit.

Pairing Suggestions

This frozen yogurt is delicious on its own but also pairs beautifully with other flavors and textures:

• With Fruit: Serve alongside grilled peaches, fresh strawberries, or sliced bananas.
• With Cookies: Sandwich between two oatmeal or chocolate chip cookies for an ice cream sandwich.
• With Beverages: Pair with an iced herbal tea or a cold brew coffee for a refreshing treat.
• With Breakfast: Believe it or not, a scoop on top of pancakes or waffles is a game-changer.

Storage, Freezing & Reheating Instructions

Storage

Store the frozen yogurt in an airtight container in the freezer. Due to the lack of stabilizers, the texture is best on the day it’s made.

Freezing

It will keep for 2–3 weeks in the freezer, but you’ll need to let it sit out at room temperature for 10–15 minutes to soften before scooping.

Reheating

Frozen yogurt doesn’t need to be reheated, but to revive its texture, let it thaw gently rather than microwaving. Stir after softening to restore creaminess.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

• Using watery yogurt: Thick yogurt works best. If yours is thin, strain it through cheesecloth to remove excess moisture.
• Over-sweetening: Remember that freezing dulls sweetness, but too much can overpower the nutty flavor. Taste before freezing and adjust as needed.
• Skipping the chill time: If using an ice cream maker, chilling the base ensures a smoother, creamier result.
• Not blending thoroughly: Especially if using the blender method, take your time blending for a smooth texture.
• Forgetting to stir during freezing: If doing the manual method, consistent stirring is key to avoiding icy chunks.

Pro Tips

• Add vanilla extract: A splash enhances the overall flavor.
• Use roasted peanut butter: For a deeper, more intense flavor.
• Make it chunkier: Stir in crushed pretzels, chocolate pieces, or granola at the end.
• Chill your container: Before pouring in the mixture, chill your freezer-safe container to help the yogurt set faster.
• Create swirls: Drop dollops of jam or melted chocolate into the container and gently swirl with a knife before freezing.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Can I use flavored yogurt?
Yes, vanilla yogurt works beautifully and adds natural sweetness. Just reduce the added sweetener.

Is this vegan-friendly?
Absolutely, as long as you use dairy-free yogurt and milk, and a plant-based sweetener like maple syrup or agave.

What if I don’t have peanut butter?
You can substitute with almond butter, cashew butter, sunflower seed butter, or chocolate peanut butter.

Can I use a banana instead of sweetener?
Yes, a ripe banana works wonderfully and adds natural sweetness with extra creaminess.

How long does it take to freeze?
That depends on the method. The ice cream maker takes about 25 minutes; the freeze-and-stir method takes 2–3 hours.

Can I double the recipe?
Definitely. Just make sure your equipment (blender or ice cream maker) can handle the extra volume.

What’s the texture like after freezing overnight?
It will harden due to the lack of stabilizers, but softens up beautifully after sitting at room temperature for 10–15 minutes.

Can I add cocoa powder?
Of course! Add 1–2 tablespoons for a chocolate-peanut butter twist.

How do I make it keto?
Use unsweetened yogurt, a keto-friendly sweetener like stevia or erythritol, and full-fat peanut butter.

Do I need to use salt?
Just a pinch of salt really brings out the peanut butter flavor, but you can skip it if preferred.

Conclusion & Call to Action

There’s something deeply satisfying about making your own frozen dessert, especially when it checks all the boxes—easy, healthy, and absolutely delicious. This peanut butter frozen yogurt is a recipe you’ll come back to again and again, not just because it’s simple, but because it genuinely tastes that good.

Whether you’re whipping up a quick batch for yourself on a quiet night or serving it at your next summer gathering, this is the kind of treat that brings smiles all around. And the best part? You’re in control of the ingredients, the sweetness, and the mix-ins.

If you give this recipe a try, I’d love to hear how it turned out for you. Share your thoughts in the comments below, or tag me on Instagram with a photo of your frozen yogurt masterpiece. I’m always excited to see your creations and how you make the recipe your own.

Now, go grab that yogurt and peanut butter—it’s time to make some magic.

Print